The Magicians Guild & The Novice, Trudi Canavan

 in Blog  tagged reviews / trudi canavan by

The Magicians’ Guild; The NoviceTrudi Canavan Not totally sure what I think about these yet… they’re the first two of The Black Magician Trilogy, and the last book isn’t at the library here, so I’m going to have to wait till I’m back in St. Paul. They don’t have any grand, sweeping ideas or revolutionary concepts, so it would be easy to dismiss them, but this one character, the character of Akkarin, stops me. Basic plot — Sonea, a street girl, is taken into the elusive Magicians’ Guild when they discover her magic is powerful enough to manifest on its […]

Pyromancer, Don Callander

 in Blog  tagged don callander / reviews by

PyromancerDon Callander An average book… I didn’t check the publication date, but it sounds like Tolkien’s era, when fantasy was tied to a certain set of tropes — cute little fairies, mountain-dwelling dwarves, eccentric wizards… and, of course, stupid, bumbling enemies. You know the sort — every Redwall book has them — the Bad Guys who are egotistical and so cruel to their own followers that said followers defect to the Good side at the slightest hint of kindness. Also part of the equation — romance between two characters that happens just because it seems to be convenient, plastic because […]

American Gods, Neil Gaiman

 in Blog  tagged neil gaiman / reviews by

American Gods Neil Gaiman After Neverwhere, this was kind of a disappointment. It seemed more like an exercise in showing off the various gods than anything else. I put it aside for several days in the middle of it, and when I looked back at the first 100+ pages, I thought, wait a sec, what even happened? There wasn’t a single disparate event I could point out, for plot progression. (Although, you know, I could be a bit too old-fashioned, expecting plot.) And why bog Shadow down at the funeral home for what seemed like a year? I did appreciate, […]

Neverwhere, Neil Gaiman

 in Blog  tagged neil gaiman / reviews by

Neverwhere. Neil Gaiman. It’s hard to review this as a whole book, because it’s hard to think of anything but the ending. Heartbreaking, and beautiful — probably because it strikes terribly close to the bone for sci-fi and fantasy lovers. Hidden in the darkest corner of our soul, what Richard is given is our heart’s desire, what we want more than anything else in the world. But for us, unlike Richard, it is impossible. There is no doorway in the wall. That’s the heartbreaking part. The beauty is that he does, and through him we get a brief, vicarious flash […]